Top Ten Thinking Errors
In addition to the negative or unhelpful thinking described in the 'Challenging Negative Thinking' fact sheet, there are some common thinking errors that most of us make from time to time.
Thinking errors are irrational patterns of thinking that cause you to feel bad, and sometimes to act in self-defeating ways.
Whenever you find yourself feeling upset (e.g. anxious, angry, depressed, resentful, guilty, ashamed, etc) look for any thinking errors that might be contributing to the way you feel.
Challenging Your Thinking Errors
Here are 10 common thinking errors and ways to challenge them.
1. Black-and-White Thinking
When you're thinking in black-and-white, you see everything in terms of being good or bad. Either you're great, or you're a loser; if you don't look like a model you must be ugly; if you do something wrong then you are completely bad. You see everything as either good or bad, with no in-betweens.
THE CHALLENGE: Look for Shades of Grey
It is important to avoid thinking about things in terms of extremes. Most things aren't black-and-white - usually they are somewhere in-between. Just because something isn't completely perfect doesn't mean that it's a complete write-off.
• Is it really so bad, or am I seeing things in black-and-white?
• How else can I think about the situation?
• Am I taking an extreme view?
2. Unreal Ideal / Unfair to Compare
Another common thinking error is making unfair comparisons between certain individuals and yourself. When you do this, you compare yourself with people who have a specific advantage in some area. Making unfair comparisons can leave you feeling inadequate and not OK.
THE CHALLENGE: Stop Making Unfair Comparisons
• Am I comparing myself with people who have a particular advantage?
• Am I making fair comparisons?
When you filter you do two things: First you hone in on the negative aspects of your situation and secondly, you ignore or dismiss all the positive aspects.
THE CHALLENGE: Consider the Whole Picture
• Am I looking at the negatives, while ignoring the positives?
• Is there a more balanced way to look at this?
4. Personalising - The Self-Blame Game
When you personalise, you feel responsible for anything that goes wrong, even when it's not your fault or responsibility.
THE CHALLENGE: Don't Personalise
It's important to consider that not everything is your fault or your responsibility. Most things have more than one cause.
• Am I really to blame? Is this all about me?
• What other explanations might there be for this situation?
We often think we know what other people are thinking. We assume that others are focused on our faults and weaknesses - but this is often wrong!
THE CHALLENGE: Don't Assume That you Know What Others are Thinking
• What is the evidence? How do I know what other people are thinking?
• Just because I assume something, does that mean I'm right?
When you catastrophise, you exaggerate the consequences when things go wrong, and you imagine that things are or will be disastrous.
THE CHALLENGE: Decatastrophise
• What's the worst thing that can happen?
• What's the best thing that can happen?
• What's the most likely to happen?
• Will this matter in five years time?
• Is there anything good about the situation?
• Is there any way to fix the situation?
When you overgeneralise you exaggerate the frequency of negative things in your life, like mistakes, disapproval and failures. Typically you might think to yourself: 'I always make mistakes' or 'Everyone thinks I'm stupid'.
THE CHALLENGE: Be Specific - Don't Overgeneralise
• Am I overgeneralising?
• What are the facts, and what are my interpretations?
8. Fact Versus Feeling/Thinking
Sometimes you might confuse your thought or feelings with reality. You might assume, 'If I think or feel this way then my thoughts/feelings must be correct'.
THE CHALLENGE: Stick to the Facts
• Am I confusing my feelings with the facts? Just because I am feeling this way, does that mean my perceptions are correct?
• Am I thinking this way just because I am feeling bad right now?
When you use labelling you might call yourself (or other people) names. Instead of being specific (e.g. 'That was a silly thing to say') you make negative generalisations about yourself or other people (e.g 'I am ugly', 'I am dumb', 'I'm a loser', I'm boring'; 'She is an idiot'; 'He's a creep').
THE CHALLENGE: Stick to the Facts
• What are the facts and what are my interpretations?
• Just because there is something that I'm not happy with, does that mean that I'm totally no good?
10. 'Can't Standitis'
Some people get very intolerant when they have to do things they don't enjoy. They tell themselves that they can't stand certain things instead of just acknowledging that they don't enjoy them. As a result, they very easily become frustrated and angry.
THE CHALLENGE: Accept that frustration is a normal part of life, and that we can't always get what we want
• I don't enjoy it, but I can stand it.
• This is a hassle, and that's OK! Life is full of hassles.
The Effect of Challenging Thinking Errors
What is the effect of challenging your thinking errors? Does it make you feel better? Does it encourage you to change some of your behaviour?
Often it is useful to write down the changes that occur after you have challenged your thinking, as this helps you to see the advantages of working on your thoughts, and motivates you to keep doing so. You could also give ROC a go at Reach Out! Central - This gives you a space to gather evidence that helps you to challenge your negative thinking. (www.roc.reachout.com.au)
REMEMBER!! Whenever You are Feeling Bad, Try to Become Aware of Your Thoughts. If they are negative or critical, have a go at challenging them. Once you get into the habit of disputing your negative self-talk you'll find it easier to handle difficult situations, and as a result, you'll feel less stressed and more confident and in control.
Write it Down
While you are learning to identify and challenge your negative self-talk it's a good idea to write it all down. Writing down your thoughts and disputing statements in a diary or notebook helps you to develop your skills. Initially it might feel like work, but the more often you do it, the easier it will become, and the better you will feel.
Try it Out
Now that you know a few common thinking errors and how to challenge them, why don't you try it out? It might not be easy at first, and it may take some time. However, the rewards could be huge! People who choose the way they think about things, who are at peace with the past, live in the present, and are optimistic about the future, are generally happier.
Let us know how you go! You can do this by either filling in a feedback form at the bottom of the page, or by joining the discussion in the Community Online Forums in the 'Challenging Thinking Errors' thread here.
See also 10 Cognitive Thinking ErrorsMental Health
This fact sheet comes from:
Taking Charge! A Guide for Teenagers: Practical Ways to Overcome Stress, Hassles and Upsetting Emotions.
By: Dr Sarah Edelman and Louise Rémond
Foundation for Life Sciences (2005)